Oakton Coins and Collectibles is a fast and safe way to sell your Tiffany jewelry.

Sell Tiffany engagement rings and all other kinds of jewelry. We pay highly competitive prices with Evanston jewelry stores. We buy a wide variety of items including rings, watches, Tiffany necklaces, brooches, and Tiffany earrings. Our simple and fast service enables you to have money today. We will not take your jewelry away from you in a back room like some places in Evanston

We also buy and sell coins, paper money, estate jewelry, platinum, stamps, diamonds, all forms of gold / silver, and more.


Tiffany & Co. is a renowned luxury brand known for its exquisite jewelry designs. Tiffany jewelry is highly coveted, with many pieces considered timeless classics. However, there may come a time when you need to part ways with your Tiffany jewelry. Whether you are looking to downsize your collection, need extra cash, or simply want to sell a piece that no longer suits your style, selling your Tiffany jewelry can be a lucrative option. Here are some tips to help you get the best value for your Tiffany jewelry.

  1. Determine the Value of Your Tiffany Jewelry The first step in selling your Tiffany jewelry is to determine its value. The value of your jewelry will depend on several factors, including its condition, age, rarity, and the current market demand for similar pieces. You can get an appraisal from a trusted jeweler or professional appraiser to determine the value of your Tiffany jewelry.
  2. Find a Reputable Buyer Once you have determined the value of your Tiffany jewelry, you need to find a reputable buyer. You can sell your Tiffany jewelry to a jeweler, a coin shop, or an online buyer. It’s important to do your research and choose a buyer with a good reputation and a fair price policy. Look for reviews and ratings online, and consider asking for recommendations from friends or family members who have sold jewelry before.
  3. Choose the Right Selling Platform There are several ways to sell your Tiffany jewelry, including through an online marketplace, an auction house, or a consignment shop. Each platform has its advantages and disadvantages, so you need to choose the right one for your needs. For example, if you need cash quickly, a pawn shop or online buyer may be the best option. 
  4. Prepare Your Jewelry for Sale Before selling your Tiffany jewelry, it’s important to prepare it for sale. Clean the jewelry thoroughly, and take clear photos of each piece. If you have the original box, packaging, or paperwork, include it in the sale to increase its value. You can also have your jewelry professionally cleaned or repaired to increase its value and appeal to buyers.
  5. Negotiate the Sale Price When selling your Tiffany jewelry, don’t be afraid to negotiate the sale price. Buyers will often make a lower offer initially, so be prepared to counter with a higher price. However, be realistic and reasonable with your asking price. You should also be prepared to accept a fair price if it meets your needs.

Selling your Tiffany jewelry can be a great way to free up cash or make room for new pieces. By following these tips, you can ensure that you get the best value for your jewelry and find a reputable buyer who will appreciate your Tiffany treasures.